Skip navigation
Annenberg School of Communication and Journalism University of Southern California

Your Health

BMI is Misleading, Study Finds

A new study says that the body mass index may not always be a good barometer for obesity.

A new study was released Monday saying that the body mass index, which has been used for the past 180 years to determine if a person has a healthy or unhealthy weight, may be incorrectly classifying 50% of women and 20% of men as healthy when they are actually obese.

The study in the PLoS One journal suggested using a ratio of fat to lean muscle as the "gold standard" for detecting obesity and possible health problems instead of BMI.

The researchers used a costly diagnostic test called duel-energy X-ray absorptiometry, or DXA, and calculated the subject's level of obesity based on fat-composition standards used by the American Society of Bariatic Physicians.

The study's authors, Dr. Nirva R. Shah, New York's state commissioner of health, and Dr. Eric Braverman, a New York City internist in private practice, found that 20% of the study's men and 50% of the study's women shifted from normal and healthy into the obese column under the new measures. However, while the study found that more people should be classified as obese, it is hard to know whether the higher rates of obesity actually correlate to poorer health.

With the credibility of the BMI formula in question, researchers have proposed alternate ways of determining obesity including weight-loss counseling, exercise regimes and drug therapies. Simple measurements--waist circumference, hip circumference, hip-to-waist ratios--have also gained popularity as ways to distinguish between healthy and unhealthy weight.

The latest effort to calculate obesity was praised by experts who agree that the BMI is outdated and a poor way to measure a person's health, however they also said that the DXA scan, which measures bone density, may be too expensive for general use.

The study also looked at leptin, an appetite-boosting hormone secreted by the body's fat deposits, and found that it generally reflects an individual's fatness as determined by DXA. The study also showed that testing leptin levels may be a simpler and cheaper method of measuring obesity than DXA.

The study concludes by saying that physicians should also consider by taking routine measures of patients' leptin levels as an indicator of body composition and possibly a predictor of obesity-related diseases.

RELATED:

USC Study Connects Obesity and Physical Functioning in Older People

Possible Cure for "Diabesity"

Study Shows Slight Drop in Child Obesity

COMMENTS

I know an inexpensive way to determine if you are obese or not. Look in a f***ing mirror!!! What a waste of time and money.

Leave a comment
Name:
E-mail:*
URL:
Comments:*

FDA Seeks to Regulate E-Cigarettes


By Mengyi Jenny Sun and Matt Hamilton
04/24/14 | 3:21 p.m. PDT

Starting tomorrow, the public can submit comments about the FDA's proposed changes through the agency's website.

Postal Workers Oppose Mail Countertops at Staples


By Matt Hamilton and Kimberly Leoffler
04/24/14 | 2:48 p.m. PDT

Meanwhile, the Postmaster General said partnering with Staples is about "growing our business."

Weather 04/24/14

Kulture with Keavy 04/24/14

The Tease: Apr. 24, 2014

USC Women's Water Polo Hosts MPSF Playoffs

We detected that you might be on a mobile device such as an iPad or iPhone. Sorry, at this time the video box is only visible on desktop computers.
MOST POPULAR

Halloween Shooting Suspect Sentenced To 40 Years


By ATVN
04/18/14 | 12:28 p.m. PDT

The 21-year-old behind the USC Halloween shooting in 2012 was sentenced to 40 years to life in prison. 

USC Celebrates Earth Week


By Tiffany Taylor
04/21/14 | 1:39 p.m. PDT

Actor Ian Somerhalder will speak on campus in honor of Earth Day.